| Award | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 |
| Captain | Chris Richards | Paul Beinstein | Mike Mariani |
| Most Valuable Player | Zoli Hajnal | Mark Whitcomb | |
| Most Outstanding Forward | Mike Mariani | Mike Doherty | |
| Most Outstanding Back | Paul Beinstein | Jeff Hamlin | |
| Most Outstanding First-Year | Chris Meaney | Nick Williams | |
| Most Improved | Harry Singh | Jacques Brose |