$\newcommand{\sym}{\mathrm {Sym}}$ $\newcommand{\gl}{\mathrm {GL}}$ $\newcommand{\aut}{\mathrm{Aut}}$ $\newcommand{\ISO}{\mathrm{ISO}}$ $\newcommand{\det}{\mathrm{det}}$ $\newcommand{\R}{\mathbb{R}}$ $\newcommand{\F}{\mathbb{F}}$ $\newcommand{\norm}[1]{\lVert #1 \rVert}$ $\newcommand{\cT}{\mathcal{T}}$ $\newcommand{\gbinom}[2]{\genfrac{\lbrack}{\rbrack}{0pt}{}{#1}{#2}}$

CMSC 36500-1: Algorithms in Finite Groups

Spring 2011

Problems (II)


Course home | First Problem Set | Exercises from class | Homework | instructor's classes

This problem set has not been proofread by the instructor.

If you find any mistakes, please send email to the instructor.

Some notation

Letters like $G$ will denote groups. The notation $H\le G$ means that $H$ is a subgroup of $G$.

Letters like $X$ will denote graphs. A graph $X = (V, E)$ will be undirected by definition. We will use the word digraph to refer to directed graphs.

1. Symmetry of Plantonic solids

Recall that there are five Plantonic solids: tetrahedron, cube, octahedron, dodecahedron and icosahedron. The automophism group of a Platonic solid is the set of Euclidean isometries (rotation and refelction) leaving it invariant.

Exercise 1.1:
$\aut(\mathrm{Tetrahedron})\cong S_4$.

Fix a basis of $\R^n$, a linear transformation $A\in\gl(n, \R)$ can be realized by an invertible matrix $M$. $A$ is called orientation preserving if $\det(M)>0$.

Exercise 1.2:
(a) If $S$ is a full-dimensional subset of $\R^n$, then the group $G$ of the isometries of $S$ has a subgroup of index $\leq 2$ consisting of all orientation preserving elements. Denote this subgroup of $\aut(S)$ as $\aut^+(S)$.
(b) Suppose $n$ is odd, $S$ is a full-dimensional bounded subset of $\R^n$, $S=-S$. Then $\aut(S)=\aut(S)^+\times C_2$. Note that the boundedness condition can not be omitted.

Exercise 1.3:
(a) $\aut^+(\mathrm{Tetrahedron})\cong A_4$.
(b) $\aut^+(\mathrm{Cube})\cong S_4$.
(c) $\aut(\mathrm{Cube})\cong S_4\times C_2$.

2. Symmetry of graphs

Give a graph $X$, an automorphism of $X$ is a permutation of the vertices that preserves the edge relation.

Exercise 2.1:
(a) Find a graph $X$ such that $\aut(X)\cong C_3$.
(b) (Frucht's theorem, 1938) $(\forall G)(\exists X)(\aut(X)\cong G)$.

Exercise 2.2: If $X$ is a 3-regular connected graph, $e$ is an edge in $X$, then $\aut(X)_e$ (the automorphisms preserving $e$) is a 2-group.

Exercise 2.3: If $\aut(X)\cong Q_8$ ($Q_8$ is the quaternion group), then $X$ is not planar.

Exercise 2.4: If the characteristic polynomial of the adjacency matrix of $X$ is irreducible over $\mathbb{Q}$, then $\aut(X)$ is trivial.

Exercise 2.5: $X$ is connected graph, and every vertex has degree $\leq d$. Then $\aut(X)_e\in \Gamma_{d-1}$. Here $\Gamma_{k}$ is the set of groups whose composition factors are subgroups of $S_{k}$

3. Wreath product and its applications

Let $A\leq \sym(U)$, and $B\leq \sym(V)$. Let $\Omega=U\times V$. We will construct the wreath product $G = A\wr B\leq \sym(\Omega)$.

First let us describe two groups, $H$, $B^*\leq \sym(\Omega)$. For a given $v\in V$, $A$ can act on $U\times\{v\}$ by its action on $U$. Denote this action by $A(v)\leq \sym(U\times V)$. Then $H$ is defined as $\prod_{v\in V} A(v)\cong A^V$. Given $\pi\in B$, it induces an action $\pi^*$ on $\Omega$ by sending $(u,v)$ to $(u, v^\pi)$. Let $B^*=\{\pi^*\mid \pi\in B\}\leq\sym(\Omega)$. The wreath product $G=A\wr B$ is the defined as $\langle H, B^* \rangle$, the group $G$ generated by $H$ and $B^*$.

Formally, for $(a_1, \dots, a_m), (a'_1, \dots, a'_m)\in H$, and $b, b'\in B$, we define the product $ (a_1, \dots, a_m; b)(a'_1, \dots, a'_m; b') = ( a''_1, \dots, a''_m; b'')$, where $b'' = b b'$, and $a''_i = a_i a'_{i^{b^-1}}.$

Exercise 3.1 Show that $H\triangleleft G$. The follwowing 2 exercises are hints to this one.

Exercise 3.2: Recall the definition of a normal subgroup: $N\triangleleft G\ :\ (\forall g\in G)(g^{-1}Ng = N).$ Prove that it sufficient to verify the above for a set of generators of $G$.

Definitions: $g$ normalizes $N$ if $g^{-1}N g = N$.

Exercise 3.3 : Prove that $H$ normalizes $H$ and $B^*$ normalizes $H$.

Exercise 3.4 : If $K, L\leq G$ such that $KL = G$ and $K\cap L = 1$, then $|G|= |K||L|$.

Exercise 3.5 If $K, L\leq G$, $KL \leq G \Leftrightarrow KL=LK$.

Exercise$^o$ 3.6 Find two subgroups in $S_3$ such that their product is not a subgroup.

Exercise 3.7 Show that if $G = \langle K, L \rangle$, where $K\triangleleft G$, and $L\leq G$, then $G = KL$.

Corollary 3.8 $A\wr B = HB^*$.

Exercise 3.9 Explain that the action of $A\wr B$ on $U\times V$ is imprimitive.

Exercise 3.10:
(a) Show that $\aut(\mathrm{cube})\cong S_4\times S_2\cong C_2\wr S_3$.
(b) Let $Q_n$ be the $n$-dimensional cube, that is $Q_n=\{x\in\R^n\mid\norm{x}_{\infty}=1 \}$. Show that $\aut(Q_n)\cong C_2\wr S_n$.

Exercise 3.11:
(a) Let $X$ be a connected graph, then $kX$ is the graph consisting of the disjoint union of $k$ copies of $X$. Show that $\aut(kX)\cong \aut(X)\wr S_k$.
(b) As a consequence, given any graph (possibly not connected), its automorphism group is direct product of wreath products, where the direct factors are based on grouping isomorphic copies together.

4. Petersen graph

Please refer to Petersen graph for the definition of Petersen graph.

Exercise 4.1:
(a) Show that $\aut(\mathrm{Petersen graph})$ has a subgroup of order 30. Hint: dihedral group of order 10.
(b) Show that $\aut(\mathrm{Petersen graph})\cong S_5$. Hint: Try to identify triples of edges preserved by automorphisms. Some drawing of Petersen's graph in this page may help you.

Next we review the symmetries of dodecahedron and note a connection with Petersen's graph.

Exercise 4.2:
(a) $\aut(\mathrm{Dodecahedron})\cong A_5\times C_2$, and $\aut^+(\mathrm{Dodecahedron})\cong A_5$.
(b) Explain that $A_5\times C_2\not\cong S_5$.
(c) Explain that Petersen graph can be embedded to the projective plane by identifying opposite vertices of the dodecahedron.

5. Line graphs and tournaments

Given a graph $X=(V, E)$, the line graph of $X$, denoted $L(X)=(E, F)$, is a graph whose vertices are the edges of $X$. Two edges (vertices in $L(X)$) are adjacent if they share a vertex in $X$. Note that every automorphism of $X$ naturally induces an automorphism of $L(X)$.

Exercise 5.1:
(a) Show that if $(\forall v\in V)(\mathrm{deg}(v)\geq 4)$, then $\aut(X)\cong \aut(L(X))$.
(b) Show that the natural homomophism from $\aut(X)$ to $\aut(L(X))$ can be not onto and not faithful.
(c) Prove that the complement of $L(K_5)$ is isomorphic to Petersen graph.

A tournament is a digraph obtained by assigning a direction to every edge in $K_n$. Note that the number of tounaments on $n$ given vertices is $2^{\binom{n}{2}}$.

Exercise 5.2: For a tournament $T$, $\aut(T)$ is solvable. Recall that the Feit-Thompson theorem states that every finite group of odd order is solvable. Show that the Feit-Thompson theorem implies the above and vice versa.

6. Automorphism group of trees

Recall that a tree is a graph without cycles.

Exercise 6.1:
(a) If $P$ is a Sylow $p$-subgroup of $S_{p^k}$, then $P\cong C_p\wr C_p\wr\dots\wr C_p$ ($k$ times).
(b) Show that te automorphism group of the depth-$h$ $k$-ary tree is $S_k\wr S_k\wr\dots\wr S_k$ ($h$ times). In particular, note that the automorphism group of depth-$h$ binary tree is isomorphic to the Sylow 2-group of $S_{2^h}$.

Let $\cT=\{\aut(T)\mid T \text{ is a tree}\}$. We remark that $\cT$ contains identity (trivial automorphism), and is closed under direct product and wreath product.

Exercise 6.2:
(a)Exhibit a non-trivial tree with trivial automorphism group.
(b) Show that $\cT$ is closed under direct product. (Hint: the center of a tree is a vertex or an edge fixed by all automorphisms. Show that every tree has a center.)
(c) Show that $\cT$ is closed under wreath product.

7. Cayley graphs

Given a group $G$ and $S\subseteq G$, $1\not\in S$, the Cayley graph $\Gamma(G, S)=(G, \{\{g, sg\}\mid g\in G, s\in S\})$.

Exercise 7.1:
(a) $\Gamma$ is vertex transitive. (Recall that a graph $G$ is vertex-transitive if for any pair of vertices $v$ and $v'$, there exists $\phi\in\aut(G)$ such that $\phi(v)=v'$.)
(b) $\Gamma$ is connected if and only if $S$ generates $G$.
(c) If $S$ is a minimal set of generators of $G$, then $K_{3, 5}\not\subseteq\Gamma$.
(d) If $\Gamma(C_p, S_1)\cong\Gamma(C_p, S_2)$, then $(\exists c,\, c\nmid p)(S_2=cS_1)$.

The diameter of a group $G$ w.r.t. $S\subseteq G$ is $\mathrm{diam}(G, S)=\mathrm{diam}(\Gamma(G, S))$.

Exercise 7.2:
(a) Prove $\langle (12), (12\dots n)\rangle=S_n$.
(b) Show that $\mathrm{diam}(S_n, \{(12), (12\dots n)\})=\Theta(n^2)$.

8. Projective plane

A finite projective plane is a triple of sets $(P, L, I)$, where $P$ is the set of points, $L$ the set of lines, and $I\subseteq P\times L$ describes the incidence relation of a point being on a line. Such a triple is a finite projective plane if it satisfies the followin axioms: (1) for every two points there is a unique line passing them; (2) every two lines intersect at a unique point; (3) there are four points not on a line.

It can be shown that on a finite projective plane, there exists $n$ such that every line contains $n+1$ points and every point lies on $n+1$ lines. This $n$ is called the order of the projective plane. The automorphism group of a projective plane is the set of permutations of vertices preserving collinearity.

The Fano plane is the smallest finite projective plane of order 2. See Fano plane on Wikipedia.

Exercise 8.1: Let $F$ be the Fano plane. Prove that $|\aut(F)|=168$. (In fact, $\aut(F)\cong PSL(3, 2)$, which is the next smallest simple group after $A_5$.)

Exercise 8.2:
(a) For every prime power $q$, construct a projective plane of order $q$. (Hint: for $v\in\F_q^3$, $v\neq \overrightarrow{0}$, let $\underline{v}=\{u\in\F_q^3\mid u=r\cdot v, r\in\F_q, r\neq 0\}$. $\underline{v}$ is called the homogeneous coordinate of $v$. $P$ and $L$ will be homogeneous coordinates.) Planes constructed in such a way are called Galois Planes.
(b) Show that the Fano plane can be constructed as above. Describe the homogeneous coordinates and lines on the Fano plane.

Exercise 8.3: Given a projective plane $L$ of order $n$, and $L'\subsetneq L$ is a subplane. Then $L'$ has order $\leq\sqrt{n}$, and this is tight infinitely often.

Exercise 8.4: For a projective plane $L$, prove that $|\aut(L)|\leq n^{O(\log\log n)}$. Verify this for Galois planes.

9. Gaussian binomial coefficients

Given a vector space $V=\F_q^n$, the Gaussian binomial coefficient $\gbinom{n}{k}_q$ is defined to be the number of $k$-dimensional subspaces of $V$.

Exercise 9.1: Calculate Gaussian binomial coefficient $\gbinom{n}{k}_q$ from its definition. Prove that $\lim_{q\to 1^+}\gbinom{n}{k}_q=\binom{n}{k}$.

Exercise 9.2: Calculate $|\gl(n, q)|$, $|\mathrm{SL}(n, q)|$ and $|\mathrm{PSL}(n, q)|$.